One Set: First Snow of the Year-> O Come All Ye Faithful[1], God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen[1], Angel of Harlem[2]-> Here We Come a Caroling[1], One of These Days, Last Payphone on the Island-> Happy Christmas (War is Over)[3], River[4], Colonial Homes-> Landslide[5], Feliz Navidad[6], Silver Bells[1], Queen, Santa Claus is Comin' to Town[7], The First Noel[1], The Half of It, Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas[1], Higher and Higher[8]-> White Christmas[1], Part of Your World[9], December, Dusk
Encore: Fairytale of New York[10], A Long December[11], It's in Every One of Us[12]-> Christmas, Silent Night[1]-> Together at Christmas[12]
[1] Traditional
[2] U2 cover
[3] John Lennon & Yoko Ono cover
[4] Joni Mitchell cover
[5] Fleetwood Mac cover
[6] José Feliciano cover
[7] The Crystals cover
[8] Jackie Wilson cover
[9] The Little Mermaid cover
[10] The Pogues cover
[11] Counting Crows cover
[12] The Muppets cover